Does Texas Have a 25% Roof Replacement Rule?

Where the 25% rule comes from, and what decides repair vs. replacement in Texas.

Shingle roof with wind-torn and missing shingles exposing the underlayment after a storm.

No. There's no statewide 25% roof rule in Texas. The rule people mean comes from Florida's building code, and the national codes Texas cities use dropped their version of it more than 20 years ago. Whether storm damage gets repaired or the whole roof gets replaced here comes down to the insurance policy, what a repair can actually fix, and local code. Here's how each one works.

Where the 25% rule comes from

The rule is written into the Florida Building Code, Existing Building, Section 706.1.1. It says that no more than 25% of a roof, or of a roof section, can be repaired, replaced or recovered in a 12-month period unless the whole roof or section is brought up to current code. Florida added an exception for roofs already built to its 2007 code or later.

The national model codes had a similar provision in their 2000 editions. It was removed starting with the 2003 International Building Code and International Residential Code, and it hasn't come back. San Antonio adopted the 2024 editions of those codes in January 2025.

It still comes up because so much roofing and insurance content online is written for Florida, and the number sounds like a rule of thumb.

What actually decides repair vs. replacement in Texas

  • Your policy and the adjuster. After a hail or wind claim, the insurance company's adjuster decides how much of the roof is damaged and what the policy covers. That decision, not a percentage in the code, sets what gets paid for.
  • Whether a repair is possible. Some damage can't be repaired well. Older shingles can be too brittle to lift and reseal without breaking, and a discontinued shingle may have no match. A repair that can't hold up isn't a real option.
  • Local code. When a roof is replaced, the new roof has to meet the code the city has adopted. Code also requires a full tear-off when a roof already has two layers or the old roof is too deteriorated to build on.
  • Code upgrades and coverage. If code requires work beyond replacing what was damaged, ask your agent whether your policy includes ordinance or law coverage, which is the part of a policy that can pay for code-required upgrades.

Our rule for repairs

We recommend a repair only when it will keep water out for at least one to two years. If the damage is limited and the roof has life left, we'll tell you to repair it. If the roof is past that point, a roof replacement is the better use of the money, whether or not insurance is involved.

How a storm claim works with us

We inspect the whole property and document the damage with photos. When the damage qualifies, we help you start the claim, meet the adjuster at the property, and work with your insurance company through the process. Texas law doesn't allow a roofer to act as your public adjuster or negotiate the claim for you, so be wary of anyone who offers to. Our storm damage page explains the full process, and our guide to choosing a roofing contractor covers the other red flags.

If a storm has come through, start with a roof inspection. It's at no cost, and the photos are what your claim will rely on.

Sources: Citizens Property Insurance, Florida Building Code 706.1.1, NRCA, reroofing code compliance, City of San Antonio codes and ordinances.

USA Home & Commercial
USA Home & Commercial Team
get started today

Still Have Questions?

Whatever you're dealing with, we're happy to take a look and tell you straight.