When a new roof can go over the old one, and when code requires a tear-off.

Often, yes. A recover puts a new roof system over the existing one, and it typically costs about 30% less than tearing the old roof off. But it only works when the existing roof meets a few conditions, and building code rules some roofs out entirely. The deciding facts aren't visible from the surface, so they come from testing the roof, not from looking at it.
In a recover, the old membrane stays in place. A recover board goes over it to give the new system a clean, flat base, and the new membrane, often TPO, goes on top. There's less removal and haul-off, the building stays dried in throughout, and the work usually goes faster. That's where the savings come from.
The building codes most Texas cities use, including the 2024 codes San Antonio adopted in January 2025, require a full tear-off down to the deck when:
When a tear-off is required, every layer comes off to the deck. Peeling off only the top layer and recovering what's underneath isn't allowed.
The most common reason a recover gets ruled out is water trapped in the existing insulation. Wet insulation adds weight, loses most of its insulating value, rots or rusts the deck over time, and can blister the new membrane from below. You usually can't see it from the roof surface. Core samples, small cuts through the roof down to the deck, show what's inside. An infrared or moisture scan maps how much of the roof is wet. When only part of the roof is wet, the wet sections can sometimes be cut out and replaced and the rest recovered. When most of it is wet, it's a tear-off.
Even when a recover is allowed, a tear-off can be the better long-term choice. It lets the crew see and repair the deck, add insulation, and fix drainage at the source, and it resets the building to a single layer, which keeps a recover available for the next roof.
We start with an inspection, take core samples where needed, and give you a written report within 24 to 48 hours. Moisture or infrared scans are available at added cost when the roof is large or the core samples are mixed. From there we price repair, recover and tear-off side by side. We recommend repair only when it will keep water out for at least one to two years. Our post on what a commercial roof inspection includes explains that step.
For the full project, from scoping bids to keeping the building running during the work, see planning a commercial roof replacement, and for the most common recover membrane, what TPO roofing is. Our commercial roof replacement page covers the systems we install. Request a bid to get the inspection scheduled.
Whatever you're dealing with, we're happy to take a look and tell you straight.